Dock, Dine, & Unwind

At Papa Joe's Waterfront

Where every meal comes with a view and every visit feels like a getaway.

Hours of Operation

Sun – Thu …… 11:00 am – 10:00 pm

Fri – Sat …… 11:00 am – 11:00 pm

Wednesday …… CLOSED

Main dining room CLOSED Daily 3:30pm-5pm. We do NOT seat during this time.

*Tiki Bar and Lawn Remain Open*

Flavors to Savor at Sunset

Multiple menus tailored to every setting—from our lively Tiki Bar and serene lawn to our lunch and dinner offerings.

Locally Inspired Cuisine

Crafted by our esteemed chef, each dish showcases the freshest local flavors for a truly extraordinary experience at Papa Joe's.

Hours of Operation

Flavors to Savor at Sunset

Multiple menus tailored to every setting—from our lively Tiki Bar and serene lawn to our lunch and dinner offerings.

Locally Inspired Cuisine

Crafted by our esteemed chef, each dish showcases the freshest local flavors for a truly extraordinary experience at Papa Joe's.

We do not seat customers in the dining room between the hours of
3:30 pm and 5:00 Pm ~ *Tiki Bar and Lawn Remain Open*

Welcome to
Papa Joe's Waterfront

Islamorada, Florida Keys

Welcome to the reimagined Papa Joe’s Waterfront, a beloved treasure reborn in 2024 on the historic grounds of the original 1938 site. Once a quintessential stop on the Overseas Highway, our new venue melds nostalgia with modern dining experiences. From our lively Tiki Bar (21+) to the family-friendly lawn and elegant dining room with sweeping ocean and bay views, there’s something for everyone. Enjoy our diverse menus, relax in one of our private oceanfront suites, or dock your boat and stay awhile. Locally owned and operated, we invite both locals and tourists to rediscover the charm of Papa Joe’s Waterfront in Islamorada, Florida.

Sunning Waterfront Location

Papa Joe's Waterfront offers unmatched sunset views over both the Atlantic and Bay—Providing the BEST sunsets in the Upper Keys.

Diverse Menu Options

Multiple menus tailored to every setting—from our lively Tiki Bar & serene lawn to our lunch & dinner offerings.

Relaxed Atmosphere

Whether you're dining on our lawn, at the Tiki Bar, or inside our main dining area, the ambiance is designed for relaxation and enjoyment, making every visit a memorable one.

Tiki Bar
21+ only

Enjoy exclusive drinks at our Tiki Bar, a 21+ oasis offering a curated selection of cocktails perfect for toasting to the stunning views.

Established 1938 Reimagined 2024

At Papa Joe’s Waterfront, we offer tailored dining experiences with separate menus for different settings. In our dining room, guests can indulge in a refined menu featuring a variety of exquisite dishes, perfect for a more formal dining experience. For those enjoying the relaxed atmosphere of our Tiki Bar or the lawn area, we provide a vibrant Tiki Bar menu, full of flavorful bites and creative cocktails designed to complement the casual, scenic outdoor setting. Each menu is crafted to enhance your dining experience, whether you’re looking for sophistication or a laid-back meal by the water.

Popular Menu Items

Discover our crowd favorites: Tuna Nachos, the Savory & Sweet Watermelon & Burrata Salad, and our signature Spicy Margarita, all served against the backdrop of breathtaking waterfront views.

  • MM 79
    MM 79

    Grey Goose Vodka, St. Germaine, Lemon, Topped with Pierre Sparr Cremant Brut

  • Spicy Margarita
    Spicy Margarita

    Spicy Margarita

  • PJ's Sunset
    PJ's Sunset

    Bombay, Passionfruit, Pineapple juice, Lime, Cherry

  • Double Trouble
    Double Trouble

    Pilar Blonde and Dark Coconut Cream, OJ, Orgeat

  • Pom & Prickly Pear Margarita
    Pom & Prickly Pear Margarita

    Pom & Prickly Pear Margarita

  • Tuna Nachos
    Tuna Nachos

    Our tuna nachos are based on the classic Florida Keys dish that is served on wonton chips. Shrimp Chips are very common in Southeast Asia, these are their potato chips (in comparison to America) and are naturally gluten-free and made with tapioca flour. We use fresh Yellowfin Tuna not frozen gas flushed Tuna. Fresh Tuna is often darker red, where as the gas flushed frozen tuna is a bright pink. Unfortunately, most guests are used to this bright pink color in Tuna. It is our responsibility to educate our guests on these facts and what we believe in.

  • Seasonal Fruit & Burrata Salad
    Seasonal Fruit & Burrata Salad

    Italian-inspired shareable salad. Arugula is seasoned with a sherry vinaigrette. Everything is drizzled with balsamic glaze, and garnished with candied almonds, black salt, and Seasonal Fruit.

  • Chips & Guac
    Chips & Guac

    Pico De Gallo, Tropical Fruit Salsa, Queso Blanco, Yucca Arepas, Crispy Plantain Chips.

  • Plantain Crusted Mahi Mahi
    Plantain Crusted Mahi Mahi

    Tropical Fruit Salsa, Pickapeppa Rum Butter

  • Ribeye
    Ribeye

    Chargrilled with a blend of herbs and spices, garnished with cippolini onion and steak sauce. Served with a side of your choice.

"Great location, beautiful sunset, incredible service"

- Paige Kingman
Share Your Memories from Papa Joe's Waterfront

Leave us a
Review

Enjoyed your visit? Click here to share your experience and help others discover the magic of Papa Joe’s Waterfront!

Explore the Many Ways to Enjoy Papa Joe's

From boat to car, locals to tourists, and kids to canines, discover endless enjoyment at our versatile waterfront oasis. Engage in lawn games, enjoy kiosk ordering from our Tiki Bar Menu, sip cocktails at our 21+ Tiki Bar with sunset panoramic views, or dine inside with stunning views through expansive windows. Papa Joe’s promises an unforgettable day or night for all. We are the best family place in town!

Best Sunset in the Florida Keys

Your Papa Joe's Adventure Begins Here

Anchor your day with us at Papa Joe’s Waterfront, where every meal comes with a view and every visit feels like a getaway.

Private Events

From weddings to corporate gatherings, find everything you need for your special event with us! Contact us to start planning your event.

Our Store

Discover our online store and shop for Papa Joe's Waterfront hats, shirts, and gift cards. We ship our merchandise directly to your doorstep!

Live Webcam

Experience real-time views of Islamorada's ocean, bay, and breathtaking sunsets on our live webcam—bringing the beauty of the Florida Keys directly to you!

Gift Cards

Treat your loved ones to the gift of unforgettable dining experiences with our exclusive gift cards! Purchase a gift cared online today!

Private Fishcamp Suites

Escape to a world of luxury and serenity at our waterfront fishcamp suites.Our 3rd floor suites boast breathtaking panoramas of both the tranquil ocean and the bay.

Careers

Papa Joe’s Waterfront, Islamorada's newest and most beautiful Restaurant & Tiki Bar, is seeking enthusiastic individuals to join our exceptional team!

Get in Touch

Contact Us

79786 Overseas Highway
Islamorada FL, 33036
RESERVATIONS

we are not currently taking reservations

At this time we are not currently taking reservations. We apologize for the inconvenience.

Join Us for a Curated Dining Experience

In Our Iconic Location.

Established 1938, Reimagined 2024 – Papa Joe’s: Where Tradition Meets Modern Culinary Excellence. Join Us by the Water for Cold Beer, Stunning Sunsets, and the Best Views from Atlantic to Bay.

1938 - 2010

The original Papa Joe's stood for almost 75 years before its demolition in 2010.

2024

The reimagined Papa Joe's Waterfront opened in 2024 in the same footprint.

Premium Ingredients
100%
Locally Owned
100%
Family Friendly
100%
Service quality
100%

What Patrons Say About Papa's

People Rated our restaurant

5/5
Average rating 5 / 5

"The atmosphere, staff, and sunset views at Papa Joe’s are absolutely amazing!! The only thing better than the ocean and bay front views is the food!! I Highly recommend!!"

Melina Miller
Melina Miller

"The atmosphere is crazy.... best conch chowder I've had in a long time if not ever. Amazing fish. Staff is super, wish I would of found Papa Joes 3 days ago. Wear a long sleeve shirt, little breezy this time of year. But 5 star tonight"

Brent Ackerman
Brent Ackerman

Designation

"Amongst the BEST food and atmosphere anywhere in the Keys!! Newly opened and clearly the owner manager is not messing around!! From the location (waterfront), to decor (island vibe), to top quality ingredients, food preparation and creative presentation, nice drink selection and fabulous service it’s a first class 10 outta 10 experience! Don’t pass this place by - take it up a notch and go for the sunset!

Traci A
Traci A

"Delicious food! Indoor or outdoor dining and you can watch the sunset. Overall the place is a must-visit.” I had the delicious watermelon burrata salad! My family had the burgers and fresh fish sandwiches. Great food and service! Also loved the appetizer tuna nachos."

Gloria Garrido-Miske
Gloria Garrido-Miske

Customer

"We went with our entire family tonight for dinner and it was absolutely amazing! The views are incredible, the food was great and the service was phenomenal. We will most definitely be back. The lower level and the upper tiki bar looked so fun. We’ll be bringing all our friends there."

Taylor DiCicco
Taylor DiCicco

Customer

Welcome to Papa Joe's

Got Questions?

We've Got Answers!

Check out our FAQ for all the details you need about our pet policies, reservations, parking, and more!

Skip to content