FAQ
Popular Questions
Yes, pets are welcome on our property, except inside the dining room. Pets must be kept on leashes, and owners are responsible for cleaning up after them. If a pet is unfriendly or causing a disturbance, we may ask you to leave.
No, we operate on a first-come, first-served basis. For large groups (up to 25 people), please email our events team for accommodation.
We offer ample parking, but we encourage using ride-sharing apps like Uber, Freebee, and Lyft due to limited space in the Keys.
Our docks are reserved for restaurant and bar patrons on a first-come, first-served basis.
No, we do not offer "Cook Your Catch" services
Unfortunately, no, we do not allow public use of our boat ramp.
Restaurant
- 79786 Overseas Highway, Islamorada FL, 33036
- [email protected]
- (305) 433-4662
Oper Hours
- Mon - Thurs 11:00 - 10:00 pm
- Fri - Sat 11:00 - 11:00 pm
- Sunday .... 11:00 - 10:00 pm
- Wednesday .... CLOSED
Original Papa Joe's Opens
in the exact same location as the current establishment.
1938
2010
Original Papa Joe's is Demolished
The original building withstood many hurricanes but not the economy.
Ground Breaking of new building
The new owners began construction on the new building.
2022
2024
Papa Joe's Waterfront Opens
March 1st, 2024, we opened our doors to the reinvented Papa Joe's.
1992
We Present
1998
Best Dishes menu
2010
Winner Awards
2020
Branches Resto
Join Us for a Curated Dining Experience
In Our Iconic Location.
Established 1938, Reimagined 2024 – Papa Joe’s: Where Tradition Meets Modern Culinary Excellence. Join Us by the Water for Cold Beer, Stunning Sunsets, and the Best Views from Atlantic to Bay.
1938 - 2010
The original Papa Joe's stood for almost 75 years before its demolition in 2010.
2024
The reimagined Papa Joe's Waterfront opened in 2024 in the same footprint.